On 2/15/2026 10:27 AM, Adam H. Kerman wrote:
Arthur Lipscomb <arthur@alum.calberkeley.org> wrote:
My Bloody Valentine 3D (3D blu-ray)
I've got a question. With digital projection in movie theaters, does
this mean that these days the 3D effect is created the same way for both
home viewing and viewing in theater?
I'm not sure. But I think maybe not.
I do not believe this was shot in 3D so it would have had to be
converted to 3D for both the theater and home video. I know in the
theater it used real 3D (not anaglyph) but the first blu-ray release
used the old anaglyph red/blue glasses so this is a conversion to the
modern home video 3D format that they have in theaters today.
Also, I think the studio releasing the disc may handle the 3D conversion
for home media, and that's not necessarily the same studio that released
it in theaters.
Here is part of a review that discusses it:
"...My Bloody Valentine 3D blows its anaglyph predecessor out of the
water, and in terms of raw 3D capabilities as compared to other Blu-ray
3D releases both live-action and animated, it falls somewhere in the
middle of the pack. And now onto the more comprehensive review. My
Bloody Valentine 3D is quite possibly the most frustrating full HD 3D
release yet. Not because it's necessarily poor -- it's worlds better
than the German release of Clash of the Titans -- but because it
fluctuates between awesome and dull with most every scene. Lengthy and mesmerizingly deep imagery transports viewers to the sleepy mining town
in some scenes, while the image falls somewhat flat in others. The
definition of the 3D imagery is seamless here, but it's accompanied by ridiculously heavy ghosting there. My Bloody Valentine 3D is a film of
visual contrasts; the dark mine scenes and various nighttime segments
offer far less in the way of depth and detailing as compared to the
brighter daytime scenes. The 3D effects work in the same way, with the
image looking almost seamless by day and far more sloppy and prone to
ghosting at night..."
https://www.blu-ray.com/movies/My-Bloody-Valentine-3D-Blu-ray/16128/
For comparison, this is from the review of the review of the just
released Friday the 13th part 3 3D disc which has had multiple 3D
releases from different studios:
"Released on 3D Blu-ray by Turbine Media, Friday the 13th Part 3 3D is presented in 1080p MPEG-4 MVC encoded high- definition in the original theatrical aspect ratio of 2.35:1 widescreen. The high-definition
presentation is exceptional on the release. The transfer appears
naturally filmic and the fine film grain adds a lot to the experience.
The old-school cinematography and visuals are well-reproduced on the
release.
The 3D presentation is outstanding and provides so much creativity to
Friday the 13th Part 3. The original 3D Blu-ray release by Shout Factory
was one met with a myriad of criticisms by 3D fans for having a few
errors during the 3D transfer. As such, the original release was met
with some controversy within the enthusiast community. Turbine Media
decided to go back to the 3D presentation and work on resolving the
errors and complaints of fans. The result is a more fine-tuned 3D
presentation meant to address some of the original errors and
shortcomings on the Shout Factory 3D Blu-ray.
As one of the most requested classic 3D films ? and one of the most
requested 3D films to be revisited on the 3D Blu-ray format with a new presentation ? Turbine Media spent extra time and effort to ensure the original theatrical 3D presentation was preserved and any slight errors
or inconsistencies that were previously unaddressed would be resolved.
The end result is a pleasing upgrade for 3D enthusiasts wanting to own
the most definitive home media presentation of the horror classic. It is
a must-own release for anyone who wants the best presentation available
of Friday the 13th Part 3 3D."
https://www.blu-ray.com/movies/Friday-the-13th-Part-3-3D-Blu-ray/63514/#Review
One thing of note, modern 4K players cannot do modern 3D. I don't
understand the technology to explain why not. But in a first for my collection at least, I have the Nightmare on Elm Street 4K box set and
that includes the Elm Street 6 in 3D using the old anaglyph technology.
I *wish* they had converted it to modern 3D, but I understand they could
not have included the modern 3D on the 4K disc, so maybe that's why they didn't bother. I haven't watched it *yet* so I can't speak to the
quality of 4K anaglyph.
I also have, but haven't watched it yet, the new "Turbine Media" Friday
the 13th 3D disc. I watched the old Friday the 13th 3 3D blu-ray
anaglyph 3D version, and it was just so-so. Then I picked up the Shout Factory Friday the 13th 3D version which had the modern 3D conversion
and it looked a lot better. I am now looking forward to watching the
new and improved Turbine Media 3D conversion as I'll be going through
Friday the 13th and Elm Street very soon.
--- PyGate Linux v1.5.11
* Origin: Dragon's Lair, PyGate NNTP<>Fido Gate (3:633/10)